Debate Primer: American Patriotism

Tomorrow, PU will be debating whether or not American patriotism is good. Here are a few links on the topic to read.

US-specific works

Try Patriotism | Noahpinion [~2,400 words]. In this piece, blogger Noah Smith argues that the American left and right alike both engage in anti-patriotic politics and that the Democrats should embrace patriotism due to its popularity.

Patriotism Isn’t an Option for Everyone | The Atlantic [~900 words]. Sasha Banks writes about her experiences in the US as a Black person and why she dislikes patriotism.

The Happy Patriot, the Unhappy Nationalist | The Atlantic [~900 words]. Arthur C. Brooks writes about how patriotism and nationalism can affect people’s well being.

Abstract and semi-abstract works

Patriotism | Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy [~8,900 words]. A comprehensive overview of the current philosophical literature on patriotism.

In Defense of Reasonable Patriotism | Brookings Institution [~4,300 words]. Political scientist William Galston argues that being partial towards one’s own political community is permissible.

Patriotism Is Like Racism | Ethics (philosophy journal) [3,400 words]. In this paper, philosopher Paul Gomberg argues that even a moderate version of patriotism can’t be reasonably defended, arguing instead that patriotism is analogous to racism.

"Patriotic Pampered Pocket Pooch Posing Proudly" by Randy Son Of Robert is licensed under CC BY 2.0